The Adaptation of Modern Housing Heritage: Authenticity and Integrity in the Case of Cité Modèle
Submitted: 2024-09-29
|Accepted: 2024-12-09
|Published: 2024-12-18
Copyright (c) 2024 VITRUVIO - International Journal of Architectural Technology and Sustainability
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Downloads
Keywords:
adaptation, authenticity, Cité Modèle, integrity, modern housing heritage
Supporting agencies:
A preliminary version of this paper will be presented in the 2024 International Conference on Architecture, Technology, and Innovation (ATI), held on October 3-4, 2024, in Izmir, Türkiye
Abstract:
The post-war social housing estate, Cité Modèle (Model City) in Laeken-Brussel (BE) was designed with CIAM principles in 1950s as a high-rise modern residential district where different types of dwellings integrated with car-free zones, wide green areas and various social facilities. Today it is an exceptional urban site in the history of modern architecture in Belgium. However, physical deterioration and socio-economic vulnerability necessitated the adaptation of the settlement in 2005, leading to the preparation of a masterplan which included a twelve-year of rehabilitation programme. Different types of interventions, both prior to this masterplan and in accordance with it, have led to changes in different attributes of this living heritage site. This paper aims to discuss the impacts of various conservation and adaptation strategies on the authenticity and integrity of the modern housing heritage, while considering expanding and questioning their definitions. The methodology includes literature review, field surveys, case study analyses, and comparative tabular evaluations to explore the dimensions of authenticity and integrity in modern housing heritage. The research on this case study has the potential to address a notable question in the literature on both architectural conservation and design based on the dialogue between continuity and change, and the re-interpretation of authenticity and integrity regarding a living modern heritage site.
References:
Atelier M Architects+Planners (n.d.) Modelwijk. [Online]. https://www.a-map.be/modelwijk (accessed 18 March 2024).
Ayón, A. (2009). Historic Fabric vs. Design Intent. Journal of Architectural Conservation, 15(3), 41-58. https://doi.org/10.1080/13556207.2009.10785054
B2Ai Architects (n.d.) Modelwijk Laken: Respect for the heritage of Renaat Braem. [Online]. https://b2ai.com/en/projects/modelwijklaken/ (accessed 17 April 2024).
Bos, M. (2022). Contemporary continuity of an introverted heritage site: The case of the Cité Modèle of Heysel (Brussels, Belgium). In: C.J. Such, M.P. Figueres, A. Tostões., & U. Pottgiesser (eds.), Modern Design: Social Commitment and Quality of Life. Proceedings of the 17th International Docomomo Conference. 1185-1194. 6-9 September 2022, Valencia.
Braem, R. (1958). Modelwijk Heysel Brussel. Bouwen en Wonen 1958.10, 268-292. [Online]. http://materiauxdeconstructiondapresguerre.be/history_record/modelwijk-heysel-brussel-3/ (accessed 15 March 2024).
Coloco (n.d.) Jardin du Foyer Laekenois. [Online]. https://www.coloco.org/projets/jardin-du-foyer-laekenois/ (accessed 12 April 2024).
Costa, R., & De Valk, H. (2018). Sprouted all around: The emergence and evolution of housing estates in Brussels, Belgium. In: D. Hess, T. Tammaru and M. van Ham (eds.), Housing Estates in Europe: Poverty, Ethnic Segregation and Policy Challenges, 145-166. Springer International Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-92813-5_7
Courbebaisse, A., & Issot, N. (2022). Les grands ensembles ou comment concilier réhabilitation et patrimonialisation? [Large housing estates or how to reconcile refurbishment and heritagisation?]. In Situ, 47 [Online]. https://doi.org/10.4000/insitu.34440 (accessed 15 July 2024).
Czaar Architecten (n.d.) Modelwijk: Restauratie, transformatie en uitbreiding van een hoogbouwwijk. [Online]. https://www.czaar.be/projecten/modelwijk (accessed 9 June 2024).
De Jonge, W. (2017). Sustainable Renewal of the Everyday Modern. Journal of Architectural Conservation, 23(1-2), 62-105. https://doi.org/10.1080/13556207.2017.1326555
Docomomo_us (n.d.) How to evaluate modern. [Online]. https://www.docomomo-us.org/explore-modern/explore-the-register/how-to-evaluate-modern (accessed 19 February 2024).
Foran (2010). Model District Laken. [Online]. https://foran.nl/en/projects/laken/ (accessed 6 December 2024).
García-Esparza, J.A. (2016). Re-thinking the validity of the past. Deconstructing what authenticity and integrity mean to the fruition of cultural heritage. VITRUVIO - International Journal of Architectural Technology and Sustainability 1(1), 21–34. https://doi.org/10.4995/vitruvio-ijats.2016.4595
Glendinning, M. (2021). Mass Housing: Modern Architecture and State Power — a Global History. Bloomsbury Publishing, London. https://doi.org/10.5040/9781474229302
Henket, H.J. (1998). The icon and the ordinary. In: A. Cunningham (ed.), Modern Movement Heritage, 11-14. E & FN Spon, London.
Hess, D.B., Tammaru, T., & Van Ham, M. (2018). Lessons Learned from a Pan-European Study of Large Housing Estates: Origin, Trajectories of Change and Future Prospects. In: D. Hess, T. Tammaru and M. van Ham (eds.), Housing Estates in Europe: Poverty, Ethnic Segregation and Policy Challenges, 3-31. Springer International Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-92813-5_1
ICOMOS. (1994). Nara Document on Authenticity. [Online]. https://www.icomos.org/en/charters-and-texts/179-articles-en-francais/ressources/charters-and-standards/386-the-nara-document-on-authenticity-1994 (accessed 19 September 2024).
ICOMOS. (2013). The Burra Charter. The Australia ICOMOS Charter for Places of Cultural Significance. [Online]. http://australia.icomos.org/wp-content/uploads/The-Burra-Charter-2013-Adopted-31.10.2013.pdf (accessed 20 September 2024).
ICOMOS ISC20C. (2017). Madrid-New Delhi Document. [Online]. https://isc20c.icomos.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/MNDD_ENGLISH.pdf (accessed 25 February 2024).
Jencks, C.A. (1977). The Language of Post-Modern Architecture. Rizzoli, London.
Jokilehto, J. (1994). Questions about authenticity. ICOMOS Scientific Journal, 3, 69-75.
Le Foyer Laekenois. (2016). De Modelwijk in Brussel: Een Project Dat Leeft Presentatiedossier. Brussels. [Online]. https://slrb-bghm.brussels/sites/default/files/media/press_release/documents/cm18a22_1epierre_dospres_dossierpresentation_nl.pdf (accessed 25 May 2024).
Le Foyer Laekenois. (n.d.) De Modelwijk van gisteren, vandaag en morgen. Toc-Tok: Driemaandelijkse nieuwsbrief van de Lakense Haard.
Ledent, G., & Porotto, A. (2023). Brussels Housing: Atlas of Residential Building Types. Birkhäuser, Basel. https://doi.org/10.1515/9783035625530
Les Délires Productions. (2018). Cité Modèle, Brussels-Belgium. [Online]. https://caviar.archi/cite-modele-brussels-belgium/ (accessed 19 June 2024).
Monclús, J., & Díez Medina, C. (2016). Modernist housing estates in European cities of the Western and Eastern Blocs. Planning Perspectives 31.4, 533–562. https://doi.org/10.1080/02665433.2015.1102642
Moors, M. (2024). The Ensemble Unveiled. Research by Design in Adaptive Reuse. PhD Dissertation, Hasselt University Faculty of Architecture and Arts.
Moors, M., & Plevoets, B. (2019). Re-reading the visions of the modernists of CIAM. In: R. Amoêda, S. Lira and C. Pinheiro (eds.), REHAB 2019 - Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Preservation, Maintenance and Rehabilitation of Historic Buildings and Structures, 301-310. 17-19 July 2019, Guimarães, Portugal.
Moutury, S. (2005). The model city of Heysel: The Heritage Aspect. In: J.Y. Andrieux and F. Chevalier (eds.), The reception of Architecture of the Modern Movement: Image, Usage, Heritage. Proceedings of the 7th International Docomomo Conference, 215-219. 16-19 September 2002, Paris.
Oxford Learner’s Dictionary (n.d.) Authenticity. [Online]. https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/definition/american_english/authenticity (accessed 19 February 2024).
Pierson, C. (1991). Beyond the welfare state? The new political economy of welfare. University Park, Penn State University Press, PA.
Prudon, T. (2017). Preservation, design and modern architecture: the challenges ahead. Journal of Architectural Conservation, 23(1-2), 27-35. https://doi.org/10.1080/13556207.2017.1327193
Publica Awards (n.d.). De Modelwijk in Laken. [Online]. https://publica-brussels.com/2019-heritagearchitecture/de-modelwijk-inlaken/ (accessed 22 July 2024).
Puttemans, P. (1965). La Cité Modèle à Bruxelles/Heysel. Architecture, 67, 166-168.
Région de Bruxelles-Capitale Inventaire du Patrimoine Architectural (Brussels-Capital Region Inventory of Architectural Heritage) (n.d.) Bruxelles Laeken - Cité Modèle. [Online]. https://monument.heritage.brussels/fr/Bruxelles_Laeken/Avenue_de_la_Cite_Modele/A001/38560 (accessed 19 September 2024).
Schaut, C. (2017). Tout au Nord des tropiques: une architecture moderne à Bruxelles. Clara, 1(4), 203-218. https://doi.org/10.3917/clara.004.0203
Schönig, B. (2020). Paradigm Shifts in Social Housing after Welfare-State Transformation: Learning from the German Experience. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 44, 1023-1040. https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-2427.12914
Tostões, A. (2022). Introduction: Wake Up, Sleeping Beauty! In: Tostões, A. (ed.), Modern Heritage – Reuse Renovation Restoration, 8-11. Birkhauser, Basel / DOCOMOMO International, Lisbon. https://doi.org/10.1515/9783035625097-001
Tostões, A., & Ferreira, Z. (2017a). Post-WWII housing estates in Europe: obsolescence or resilience? Detmold Conference Week 2017 – RMB Conference 2017, Detmold, Hochschule OWL.
Tostões, A., & Ferreira, Z. (2017b). The Right to Housing (1945-2017). The Preservation of Post-WWII European Neighbourhoods. UIA 2017 Seoul World Architects Congress, Seoul.
UNESCO (2023). Operational Guidelines for the Implementation of the World Heritage Convention. UNESCO World Heritage Centre, Paris.
Vink (n.d.). Project Steni Nature Modelwijk Brussel. [Online]. https://www.vink.be/nl/kunststof-toepassingen/gevelbekleding/steni/project-steni-nature-modelwijk-brussel (accessed 6 December 2024).
Wallonie-Bruxelles Architectures (n.d.) La Cité Modèle - Etude de réaménagement du site. [Online]. https://wbarchitectures.be/fr/architects/JNC-International-s-a---Joining-Nature-and-Cities-/La-Cite-Modele---Etude-de-reamenagement-du-site/724/ (accessed 19 July 2024).
Wassenberg, F. (2004). Editorial: Large social housing estates: From stigma to demolition? Journal of Housing and the Built Environment, 19(3), 223–232. [Online]. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10901-004-0691-2
Wassenberg, F., Turkington, R., & Van Kempen, R. (2004). High-rise housing estates in Europe. In: R. Turkington, R. Van Kempen and F. Wassenberg (eds.), High-rise housing in Europe: Current trends and future prospects, 1-14. Housing and Urban Policy Studies 28, DUP Science.
WDJArchitecten (n.d.). Masterplan Modelwijk, Brussel (B). [Online]. https://www.wdjarchitecten.nl/projecten/modelwijk-renovatie/ (accessed 30 July 2024).
Wijesuriya, G. (2018). Sharing Conservation Decisions: Living Heritage. ICCROM, Rome.
