Gains from trade liberalization with imperfectly competitive world markets. A note
Submitted: 2016-03-07
|Accepted:
|Published: 2011-10-22
Downloads
Keywords:
Trade liberalization, imperfect markets, monopoly, monopsony, marketing board
Supporting agencies:
Financial support received by the Italian Ministry for University and Scientific and Technological Research
thanks to Mary Bohman
Michele De Benedictis
Fabrizio De Filippis and Alex McCalla for their many valuable comments on an earlier draft.
Abstract:
The paper shows how analyses assuming perfect competition can yield a distorted estimation of the expected effects of a trade liberalization when market imperfections exist. The analytical framework adopted is very simple and three extreme imperfect market structures are considered. In the first case, the exporting country maximizes its producer and consumer surplus by intervening in the world market. The second market imperfection considered is the existence of a private firm playing the role of «pure middleman» in the world market. Then the case of a producer-owned marketing board which is granted exclusive export authority is addressed. It is shown that estimates of the impact of a tariff reduction in terms of prices and volume traded obtained assuming perfect competition when this postulate does not hold, are distorted. When domestic demand and supply functions are assumed to be linear, the impact is overestimated; a ranking of the size of such distortions in the three cases analyzed is provided. When no restriction is imposed on the demand and supply functions, the error in the estimated impact of a tariff reduction involves the magnitude as well as the sign of the expected changes in prices and volume traded. Finally, it is proved that when a private firm exerts monopoly and monopsony power in the world market, both the importing and the exporting countries may well be better off if, rather than making a move towards trade liberalization, the importing country «compensates» the exporting country by means of a direct transfer.
References:
Abbott, P.C. (1979). «Modelling International Grain Trade with Government Controlled Markets». American Journal of Agricultural Economics. February. https://doi.org/10.2307/1239496
Ackerman K.Z. and Dixit, P.M. (1999). An Introduction to State Trading in Agriculture. United States Department of Agriculture, Economic Research Service, Agricultural Economic Report n. 783. October.
Alaouze C.M., Watson, A.S. and Sturgess, N. H. (1978). «Oligopoly Pricing in the World Wheat Market». American Journal of Agricultural Economics. May. https://doi.org/10.2307/1240046
Anania, G. (2001) Modeling Agricultural Trade Liberalization. A review. Contributed paper, Annual meeting of the American Agricultural Economics Association, Chicago, August 5-8.
Bieri, J. and Schmitz, A. ( 1974). «Market Intermediaries and Price Instability: Some Welfare Implications». American Journal of Agricultural Economics. May. https://doi.org/10.2307/1238756
Carter, C. and Schmitz, A. (1979). «Import Tariffs and Price Formation in the World Wheat Market». American Journal of Agricultural Economics. August. https://doi.org/10.2307/1239439
Carter, C., and Smith, V. (2001). «The Potential Impacts of State Trading Enterprises on World Markets: the Exporting Country Case». Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics, 49. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1744-7976.2001.tb00317.x
Dixit, P.M. and Josling, T. (1997). State trading in agriculture: an analytical framework. IATRC (International Agricultural Trade Research Consortium), Working Paper #97-4. July.
Francois, J.F., McDonald, B. and Nordstrom, H. (1996). «Assessing the Uruguay Round», in W. Martin e L. A. Winters, edts. The Uruguay Round and the Developing Economies. World Bank Discussion Papers, 307.
Hertel, T.W., Brockmeier, M. and Swaminathan, P.W. (1997). «Sectoral and economy-wide analysis of integrating Central and Eastern European countries into the EU: Implications of alternative strategies». European Review of Agricultural Economics, 24. https://doi.org/10.1093/erae/24.3-4.359
Just, R.E., Schmitz, A. and Zilbermann, D. (1979). «Price Controls and Optimal Export Policies under Alternative Market Structures». American Economic Review. September.
Karp, L.S., and McCalla, A.F. (1983)«Dynamics Games and International Trade: an Application to the World Corn Market». American Journal of Agricultural Economics. November. https://doi.org/10.2307/1240451
Kawaguchi, T., Suzuki, N. and Kaiser, H.M. (1997). «A Spatial Equilibrium Model for Imperfectly Competitive Milk Markets». American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 79. August. https://doi.org/10.2307/1244426
Kolstad, C.D. and Burris, A.E. (1986). «Imperfectly Competitive Equilibria in International Commodity Markets», American Journal of Agricultural Economics. February. https://doi.org/10.2307/1241646
Lanclos, D.K., Hertel, T.W. and Devadoss, S. (1996). «Assessing the effects of tariff reform on U.S. food manufacturing industries: the role of imperfect competition and intermediate inputs ». Agricultural Economics. 14. https://doi.org/10.1016/0169-5150(96)01189-9
McCalla, A.F. (1966). «A Duopoly Model of World Wheat Pricing». Journal of Farm Economics. August. https://doi.org/10.2307/1236871
McCalla, A.F., and Josling, T.E. (1985). Agricultural Policies and World Markets, MacMillan.
McCorriston, S. (1996). «Import Quota Licenses and Market Power». American Journal of Agricultural Economics. 78. May. https://doi.org/10.2307/1243709
McCorriston, S. (2002). «Why should imperfect competition matter to agricultural economists?». European Review of Agricultural Economics. 29 (3). https://doi.org/10.1093/eurrag/29.3.349
McCorriston, S. and MacLaren, D. (2000). State Trading in Agricultural markets: A Conceptual Analysis. OECD, Directorate for Food, Agriculture and Fisheries & Trade Directorate, COM/AGR/APM/TD/WP(2000)17. February.
Paarlberg, P.L. and Abbott, P.C. (1986). «Oligopolistic Behavior by Public Agencies in International Trade: The World Wheat Market». American Journal of Agricultural Economics. August. https://doi.org/10.2307/1241538
Pick, D. and Park, T. (1991). «The Competitive Structure of U.S. Agricultural Exports», American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 73 (1). February. https://doi.org/10.2307/1242889
Sarris, A.H. and Schmitz, A. (1981). «Price Formation in International Agricultural Trade», in A.F. McCalla and T.E. Josling (edts). Imperfect Markets in Agricultural Trade. Allanheld-Osmun.
Schmitz, A., McCalla, A.F., Mitchell, D.O. and Carter, C. (1981). Grain Export Cartels. Ballinger Publ. Co.
Scoppola, M. (2000) Le multinazionali alimentari. I mercati e le politiche. Carocci, Roma.
Sexton R. and Lavoie, N. (2001). «Food Processing and distribution: an industrial organization approach», in B. Gardner and G. Rausser, edts. Handbook of Agricultural Economics: Marketing, Distribution and Consumers (volume 1B). Elsevier. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1574-0072(01)10023-X
Shaminathan, P.V., Hertel, T.W. and Brockmeier, M. (1997). European Union Enlargement: What are the Agricultural Trade Models Missing?. Annual meeting of the American Agricultural Economics Association. Toronto. July.
Thursby, M.C. and Thursby, J.G. (1990). «Strategic Trade Theory and Agricultural Markets: An Application to Canadian and U.S. Wheat Export to Japan», in C.A. Carter, A.F. McCalla and J.A. Sharples (edts.). The New Trade Theory in Agricultural Trade Research, Westview
Press. Boulder.
Veeman, M., Fulton, M. and Larue, B. (1999). International Trade in Agricultural and Food Products: The Role of State Trading Enterprises. Economic and Policy Analysis Directorate, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada. April.
Warr, P. (2001). «Welfare Effects of an Export Tax: Thailand’s Rice premium». American Journal of Agricultural Economics. 83 (4). November. https://doi.org/10.1111/0002-9092.00218
